What the district told us, and what it left out
November 13, 2026: District email to families
Superintendent Susan Yom wrote that the district had learned of "an active New York State Police investigation involving John Griffiths regarding an off-campus matter," and that the interim assistant principal was "no longer employed by the District."
The letter did not say what the investigation was about.
November 16, 2026: New York State Police
State Police announced the arrest of John Henry Griffiths, 62, of Yorktown Heights, on two felony charges: Promoting a Sexual Performance by a Child Less Than 17 (class D felony) and Possessing a Sexual Performance by a Child Less Than 16 (class E felony). He was remanded to the Westchester County Jail without bail.
Families learned what the case involved from a police press release, not from their own school district. Mr. Griffiths is presumed innocent until proven guilty. But parents had a right to know what kind of allegation involved someone with authority over their children.
A pattern, not an accident
The board hired Dr. Yom despite a record it could see. In Nyack, about 100 teachers walked out of a board meeting in protest, and the district's five unions issued a statement of no confidence in her. At a March 2024 meeting, staff alleged she bullied employees and created a hostile work environment. Nyack's board then approved a separation agreement worth about $279,000 in pay, vacation time and retirement contributions. Elmsford's board reviewed more than 50 applicants and appointed her in December 2024.
Sources: News 12 (Mar. 2024) · News 12 · Patch / Journal News · News 12 (Dec. 2024)
Then Elmsford had the same problems Nyack had. At the May 2026 board meeting, teachers raised concerns about high turnover, falling morale and changes to evaluations. A former teacher alleged that staff facing termination were pushed to resign. Parents told News 12 that the churn is hitting special-education students hardest. One parent said her child left school unsupervised four times.
Sources: News 12 (May 7, 2026) · News 12 (May 4, 2026)
Leadership shuts out the community. The Greater Hudson Valley NAACP has asked to meet with the district about complaints from families and staff of color. The district called the claims unsubstantiated, and the meeting request has stalled. When parents raised alarms about turnover, the district declined to comment. The May board meeting ended abruptly after a heated exchange between the board president and teachers. The superintendent and board president declined to comment to News 12.
Sources: News 12 (Mar. 2026) · News 12 (May 2026)
Timeline
- Dec 2022Nyack appoints Susan Yom superintendent.
- Mar 2024About 100 Nyack teachers walk out; unions vote no confidence and staff allege bullying and a hostile work environment.
- Jun 2024Nyack approves a separation agreement worth about $279,000. Yom leaves June 30.
- Dec 4, 2024Elmsford appoints Yom after reviewing more than 50 applicants.
- Jan 2, 2025Yom starts in Elmsford.
- Mar 2026The NAACP's meeting request about complaints from families and staff of color stalls.
- May 2026Parents and teachers raise alarms over 44 staff resignations; the board meeting ends abruptly.
- Jul 27, 2026Board terminates the probationary employment of Dixson's principal.
- Aug 17, 2026After a two-hour closed session, the board appoints John Griffiths, formerly Croton-Harmon's assistant superintendent, interim assistant principal for Grady and Dixson. The appointment is added as a late addendum.
- Aug 20, 2026Griffiths starts work.
- Aug 26, 2026Board certifies him as a teacher evaluator and names him to the Districtwide Safety Team.
- Sep 9, 2026Board authorizes the Superintendent to hire staff on her own through Dec. 31, with board approval afterward.
- Nov 13, 2026District tells families Griffiths left over an "off-campus matter."
- Nov 16, 2026State Police announce his arrest on two felony child sexual abuse material charges.
What the board minutes show, and don't show
We searched the official minutes of every board meeting from July 14 through September 9, 2026.
August 17, 2026: Special meeting, item 6.02
The board appointed John Griffiths Interim Assistant Principal of Alice E. Grady Elementary School and Carl L. Dixson Primary School, effective August 20, 2026 through January 8, 2027. The vote was 5–0.
The appointment was added to the agenda as a late "ADDENDUM." The vote came after a two-hour closed session to discuss "the employment history of a particular person and matters leading up the appointment of a particular person." The resolution lists no salary.
- Other appointments note the background check; his doesn't. At the July 27 meeting, the board appointed a school psychologist "pending certification and fingerprint clearance" and a nurse "pending fingerprint clearance." Griffiths's appointment includes no such language.
- Dixson lost its leadership right before school started. On July 27, the board terminated the probationary employment of Dixson's principal. On August 17, both of Dixson's top positions were filled with interim appointees added as addenda, two weeks before the first day of school.
- August 26: Six days after he started, the board certified him to evaluate teachers (item 10.02) and named him to the Districtwide Safety Team (item 10.11). The meeting also ended with an 11-minute closed session on "the employment history of a particular person." The minutes don't say who it concerned.
Source: Elmsford UFSD Board of Education minutes (BoardDocs)
Elmsford families deserve answers
Supt. Yom's record on transparency
Dr. Yom says she values this community. Again and again, families have had to learn the facts from someone else.
- Dr. Yom's November 13 letter called the Griffiths case an "off-campus matter." Why did it leave out what the investigation was about?
- Why did families have to learn the truth from the State Police and the press instead of from Dr. Yom?
- Why were Mr. Griffiths's name and the district's own August hiring announcements removed from the district website instead of explained to families?
- Did Mr. Griffiths have unsupervised contact with students? What support is being offered to students and families?
- In March 2026, the Greater Hudson Valley NAACP asked to meet with the district about complaints from families and staff of color. The district called the claims unsubstantiated and the matter resolved. Yet the district has lost 44 professional staff, about 27%, in 2025 and 2026, far above the national average of about 15%. How can low morale among staff be "unsubstantiated"? Why won't Dr. Yom sit down with them?
- When parents and teachers raised alarms in May about 44 staff resignations, about 27% of professional staff, Dr. Yom declined to comment to News 12. What is her plan to stop the turnover?
Board of Education: closed doors and late additions
The Board of Education is responsible for every hire it approves. Its own minutes raise these questions.
- Dr. Yom's Nyack record was public: a union no-confidence vote and a roughly $279,000 buyout. Why did the board choose her from more than 50 applicants?
- John Griffiths's appointment was added to the August 17 special meeting as a late "addendum." Why wasn't it on the posted agenda? Did he go through the committee-and-references process the district says it uses for principals?
- Other appointments that summer were made "pending fingerprint clearance." His wasn't. Did the district confirm his clearance before he started on August 20?
- Before voting, the board spent two hours in closed session on "the employment history of a particular person and matters leading up the appointment of a particular person." Did that discussion concern Mr. Griffiths? What did the board learn?
- On August 26, the board met in closed session again to discuss "the employment history of a particular person." Did that concern Mr. Griffiths?
- What is his salary? Why doesn't the resolution appointing him list one?
- On September 9, the board authorized the Superintendent to hire staff and issue contracts on her own through December 31, with board approval only afterward. Will the board take that authority back?
- Why is John Hecht, the son of Board President David Hecht and not a member of the board, on the Board Audit Committee that oversees the district's finances?
- Why was the August 26 meeting, which included a public hearing on the District-wide Safety Plan and a $225,000 administrative appointment, held at 8:00 a.m. on a weekday, when most working parents can't attend?
- Despite her Nyack record, the board hired Dr. Yom. Then the same complaints surfaced in Elmsford: 44 professional staff resignations in 2025 and 2026, NAACP concerns from families and staff of color, and teachers and parents raising alarms about morale this spring. The board's response was to give her more power. On September 9, it authorized her to hire staff and issue contracts on her own. Across five board meetings from July 14 to September 9, 2026, the board voted on 163 motions without a single "no" vote. Does this board ever question the Superintendent, or does it approve whatever she brings? Who is the board looking out for: the Superintendent and its own bad hiring decision, or our children?
Show up. Speak up.
Next Board of Education meeting:
Tuesday, December 1, 2026, 7:00 p.m.
Alexander Hamilton Jr./Sr. High School Auditorium
Come and ask these questions during public comment ("Recognition of the Audience"). Meeting details are posted at eufsd.org.
If you have information about the Griffiths case, or think your child may have been affected, contact the New York State Police at (914) 742-6057 and cite case #NY2601289358.
Have information to share, or want to know how you can help bring accountability and competent leadership to the Elmsford Union Free School District? Email Parents for Elmsford at parentsforelmsford@proton.me.
All sources
- New York State Police: Arrest following Internet Crimes Against Children investigation (Nov. 16, 2026)
- Elmsford UFSD email to families, "Important Information," signed by Susan Yom (Nov. 13, 2026)
- News 12: Complaints of hostile work environment levied on Nyack schools superintendent (Mar. 2024)
- News 12: Nyack unions' statement of no confidence
- Journal News: Nyack schools superintendent Susan Yom out after short, controversial tenure (June 2024)
- Patch / Journal News: Nyack settlement with Yom
- News 12: Elmsford appoints Susan Yom as superintendent (Dec. 2024)
- News 12: Tensions continue between NAACP, Elmsford School District (Mar. 2026)
- Elmsford Board of Education minutes (BoardDocs): July 27, 2026 special meeting (items 4.02, 4.06, 5.01); August 17, 2026 special meeting (items 2.01, 6.01, 6.02); August 26, 2026 (items 10.02, 10.05, 10.10, 10.11, 11.01); September 9, 2026 (item 12.08)
- The Croton Chronicle: The charges against former Croton-Harmon Assistant Superintendent John Griffiths (Nov. 17, 2026)
- News 12: Elmsford parents raise alarms over staff turnover (May 2026)
- News 12: Elmsford school tensions boil over at board meeting (May 2026)